bdeshiandClaude Opus 5
9b02bba985
The line was 78 characters at 12pt, above the 60-75 band — not the "~73"
I had recorded. That figure came from a font-metric estimate (measure
divided by the unweighted mean lowercase advance, counting no spaces) and
was simply wrong. Measured directly off the built PDF — 79 full lines,
glyphs plus inter-word gaps — 12pt ran 78 and 13pt runs 73.
So this is not restoring a lost measure, it is fixing a line that was too
long, and raising the size is the better of the two fixes: narrowing the
measure to 5.7in would have shortened the line while leaving the type
small. (Sammay proposed the size bump.)
Set through fontspec Scale=1.0833 over the 12pt class, deliberately: it
scales every size in the family, including the plate captions, but leaves
\baselineskip class-derived, so \setstretch{1.59} still yields the 22.9pt
line measured off the original. That leading is anchored to the inline
specimens and must not drift with the type size.
Verified after the build:
characters per line 78 -> 73 (target band 60-75)
pages 455 -> 479
underfull boxes 84 -> 71
Bengali/Latin ratio 2.08 -> 2.11 Scale=MatchLowercase is applied
after the main font's Scale, so
Tiro Bangla needed no adjustment
specimens still clear of the lines above and below
overfull 0, font warnings 0, reprocheck 0 tokens short
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
5.9 KiB
5.9 KiB
Ross 1988 thesis — re-typeset edition: plan (v2, confirmed 2026-09-13)
Source: 10731406.pdf — Fiona G. E. Ross, The Evolution of the Printed Bengali
Character from 1778 to 1978, Ph.D., SOAS, 1988. ProQuest scan, 431 PDF pages,
300 dpi bitonal (a few plates in colour), ABBYY text layer (NOT used as source).
Confirmed design
| Aspect | Decision |
|---|---|
| Layout | Reflowed text. \origpage{N} marks where original page N begins: bold sans number in the outer margin + thin bar in the line + page.N hyper-target. Running head shows the original page range on each edition page; edition page number in the footer |
| Notes | Footnotes become endnotes (enotez) in a final Notes section, grouped "Notes to ", keeping original numbers via \fn{n}{text}; marks link to notes, notes link back |
| Type | 13pt XCharter (Matthew Carter's Charter, extended; TeX Live, loaded by path) on a 5.95in measure — 73 characters a line, measured (79 full lines off the built PDF, glyphs plus inter-word gaps). At 12pt it ran 78, above the 60-75 comfortable band; raised to 13pt on 2026-09-15 (Sammay) via fontspec Scale=1.0833 over the 12pt class, which leaves \baselineskip class-derived so the specimen-anchored 22.9pt leading does not drift. An earlier note in these files put the 12pt line at "~73 characters" — that was a font-metric estimate, unweighted over the lowercase alphabet and counting no spaces, and it was wrong. Replaced TeX Gyre ScholaX on 2026-09-15 (Sammay): measured off the metrics, ScholaX had the smallest lowercase relative to its capitals of the faces considered, x-height/cap 0.645 against XCharter's 0.717, so its caps and ascenders dominated the page. XCharter covers all 35 non-ASCII characters here (the dots-below set defeats ETbb, Domitian, STEP, Tempora) with real small caps and oldstyle figures; Liberation Sans for marks and heads. Leading 1.59 — a 22.9pt line, which is the original's own, measured off the scan at 300 dpi by autocorrelating the row-ink profile; the inline specimens set it, not the text. Inline specimens at native size (\igscale = 72.27/300), the 74% of the line the original gives them. First line indented 1.6em, \parskip 0.15em (ragged2e resets \parindent from \RaggedRightParindent, so both are set). Ragged right and unhyphenated (\RaggedRight, \hyphenpenalty=10000, \lefthyphenmin=62) — the typescript breaks only at spaces and at hyphens it actually typed. Hanging punctuation (microtype protrusion, dashes hang far less); widows and orphans forbidden with \raggedbottom. Tiro Bangla for Bengali that shows the modern script (the Scheme of Transliteration). Bengali that shows a historical typeface is never typed: it is cut from the scan by tools/crop_inline.py and set with \ig |
| Structure | \chapstart{Title} = new page + centred bold head + PDF bookmark + notes group. One .tex per original page in src/pages/pNNNN.tex (NNNN = PDF page); \chapstart must come before \origpage in a file |
| Plates | Cropped from the 300 dpi scan by tools/crop_plate.py (scanner bars, page number, caption stripped; gutter shadow swept; deskewed when the page is out of square — the one step that resamples), embedded lossless at native resolution. \plateop{N}{no}{img}{caption} for a plate that begins page N; \plate{no}{img}{caption} otherwise. Per-page crop recipe recorded in the manifest notes column |
| Colophon | src/colophon.tex = leaf 2: description of the conversion + ProQuest notice text. Blank stamped leaf (PDF p.3) dropped and noted there |
| Editorial | Original spelling and typography stand. Handwritten corrections in the scan are adopted silently and logged in QUESTIONS.md. The author's own slips are corrected via \erratum{corrected}{as printed} and listed in the Errata section. Slips inside quoted matter are never corrected — mark \qslip{as printed} and table them in QUESTIONS.md so they can be checked against the source. A grammatical slip in the author's own prose stands exactly as printed and unmarked (Sammay, 2026-09-14, reversing the editorial [sic] first added on 2026-09-13): the seven [sic]s in this edition are all hers, and an eighth in her own notation would have been indistinguishable from them. The edition now makes no interpolation into the text at all. Other decisions confirmed by Sammay, 2026-09-13. The typographic intentions the typewriter could not realise — en-dashes for numeric ranges, true quotation marks — are applied at set time by tools/polish.py. Small caps for acronyms were removed on 2026-09-15 (Sammay): a typescript cannot set small caps, so the source defines none, and a partial whitelist left the Abbreviations page visibly inconsistent; the transcription itself stays as typed (Sammay, 2026-09-13) |
| Uncertain | \unsure{...} → unsure.log → QUESTIONS.md; never silently guessed |
| Contents | Contents and List-of-Plates entries are whole-line hyperlinks to the original page target (page.N) |
| Versioning | Git (from 2026-09-14, Sammay). The built PDF is not tracked and not archived — make regenerates it from src/ and plates/. The ProQuest scan (source/) is untracked too, being third-party; only make prep and make plate need it. Superseded design drafts stay in older-versions/ as text |
Workflow per batch
tools/prep.sh A B→scans/hi-NNN.jpg(130 dpi) +work/ocr/pNNNN.txt(tesseract scaffold).- Read every page image. For clean prose pages
tools/ocr2tex.py N printed [--head T]gives a draft; proofread word-by-word against the image, add\emph,\fn, diacritics. - Plates:
python3 tools/crop_plate.py NNNNthen a one-line\plateopfile. - Update
manifest.tsv;./build.sh; spot-check.
Remaining
Introduction pp.17–30 (PDF 19–32) → Part I from p.31 (PDF 33) … Bibliography p.419 (PDF 421) → end (PDF 431). ~245 text + ~170 plate pages: ~10–12 sessions.